Hometime vs MadeComfy

by Jacqueline Chami
September 11, 2025

Table of Contents

If you're comparing Airbnb managers, you’re likely after one thing: better returns with less hassle.

Both Hometime and MadeComfy promise full-service management, but Hometime delivers on that promise with smarter pricing, human support, and full transparency.

We handle everything, from dynamic pricing and multichannel listings to guest mangement, cleaning and maintenance. You stay in control with real-time visibility via our tech platform, and get personalised service from local experts who treat your property like their own.

What you get with Hometime

  • Advanced dynamic pricing based on real-time demand, seasonality, and local events.
  • Professionally optimised listings on Airbnb, Booking.com, Vrbo, and Hometime.io for broader exposure.
  • Local hosts who manage check-ins, guest communication, cleaning and property care.
  • A transparent Homeowner Portal for live performance tracking, revenue, and booking visibility.

What separates Hometime from MadeComfy

Tailored service. Local expertise. Real results.

Because we manage thousands of properties across Australia, we know what works, and we keep improving it. Unlike MadeComfy, where many of their on-the-ground hosts are real estate agents who prioritise selling and letting properties, Hometime’s local hosts are trained in hospitality and property care.

With Hometime, you’ll have a real person on the ground who:

  • responds to reviews,
  • vets guests with care, and
  • personalises the experience for you and your guests.

And while MadeComfy may promise higher estimates, our data shows many Hometime-managed properties outperform expectations and achieve higher net income.

Hometime vs MadeComfy

A side-by-side breakdown of what matters

Feature MadeComfy Hometime
Pricing strategy Combining dynamic pricing technology + an expert revenue management team to maximise revenue Hands-on optimisation by local experts, not just reliant on automation by dynamic pricing tools. Pricing is fine-tuned for quality, seasonality and property specifics
Platform exposure Airbnb, Booking.com, Stayz and more. Airbnb, Booking.com, Vrbo, and Hometime.io
Owner portal The Owner Dashboard with real-time updates on property performance Real-time Homeowner Portal with live revenue and bookings
Local support Most of their hosts are often real estate agents  Dedicated, trained on-the-ground local hosts who take care of your property as if it were their own
Tailored service Rigid service model with limited customisation Customisable services (e.g. owner linen, welcome packs, guest notes)
Guest experience The guest experience team uses AI-driven communication to streamline guest communication On-the-ground guest care, ongoing support and monitoring guest reviews to make sure your listing performs at its best
Cleaning & maintenance Professional hotel-level housekeeping tracked via the Owner Dashboard Professional hotel-grade cleaning managed by trusted, local professionals with consistent quality control
Forecast accuracy Higher quoted estimates that may not materialise Transparent, tiered forecasts with a proven performance record

Maximise your property’s potential with Hometime 

Performance you can trust. Service you can feel.

Hometime delivers higher returns, real-time insights and hyper-local knowledge as Australia’s largest and most trusted STR manager. You’ll get a partner who’s focused on long-term results, not just short-term wins.

Want to see how much your property could earn with us? 

Book a free earnings estimate today

Share this post
Featured